#COVID-19 : Confirmation by the Court of Appeals of Paris of the orders imposing on EDF to suspend the performance of the contracts for the sale of ARENH power due to force majeure

On August 24, 2020 By Jérémy BERNARD
1. By three rulings adopted on 28 July 2020, the Court of Appeals (Cour d’appel) of Paris confirmed the interim orders issued by the Presiding Judge of the Commercial Court (Tribunal de commerce) of Paris. These interim orders imposed on Electricité de France (hereinafter “EDF”) to suspend the performance of the framework agreements for the supply of power executed in application of the regulated access to historic nuclear electricity mechanism (hereinafter the “ARENH“) due to the fulfillment of the conditions for the application of force majeure defined in these agreements.
2. In our article of 25 May 2020, we presented the ARENH mechanism and the interim order of the Commercial Court of Paris of 20 May 2020 between EDF and Total Direct Energie, which is the subject of one of the three rulings of 28 July 2020 of the Court of Paris. Three other interim orders were adopted on the following 26 and 27 May between EDF, on the one hand, and Gazel Energie Génération, Gazel Energie Solutions and Alpiq Energie France, on the other hand, relating to the same question and taking up the solution developed in the order of 20 May 2020. All these four interim orders were appealed by EDF.
3. With its three ruling of 28 July 2020, the Court of Appeals of Paris confirmed in full the three interim orders issued between EDF, on the one hand, and Total Direct Energie, Gazel Energie Génération and Gazel Energie Solutions, on the other hand. Like the Commercial Court of Paris, it considered that the conditions for the application of force majeure provided for by the ARENH supply framework agreements were in these cases clearly met and consequently that EDF’s refusal to apply this clause blatantly called into question the principle of the binding force of contracts as well as the one prohibiting self-justice and therefore resulted in a clearly unlawful disorder.
4. To date, no information is available as to whether or not EDF intends to appeal the rulings of the Court of Appeals of Paris before the French Judicial Supreme Court (Cour de cassation) in these cases.
5. The Court of Appeals of Paris adopted a fourth ruling on 28 July 2020 relating to the interim order between EDF and Alpiq Energie France. This ruling was limited to acknowledging EDF’s withdrawal and its acceptance by the respondent.
6. Finally, the French Electricity Regulatory Commission (Commission de regulation de l’électricité), which drafted the standard model used for the preparation of the framework agreements concluded between EDF and power purchasers under the ARENH, initiated on 31 July 2020 and until 15 September a public consultation. This public consultation intends to improve the drafting of the force majeure clause to take account of the solution adopted by the Court of Appeals of Paris.
Our latest news

Distribution Contracts in France: New mandatory rules under EGALIM3 Law
French lawmakers have enacted measures to tackle the strategies employed by some distributors that have bypassed regulations through the establishment of overseas purchasing hubs. These hubs have been found to engage with French-based suppliers in a manner that undermines the French distribution agreement and contract laws. To address this, the French legislators have now clearly […]
Read
Two important information to remember from the Annual report on the control of foreign investments in France in 2022
Published on 9 May 2023, the Annual Report on the Control of Foreign Investments in France in 2022 mentions two important information. First, it presents the sanction procedure in the event of a breach of the rules on controlling foreign investments in France, which would suggest that the French Treasury could consider opening investigations in […]
Read
International Business Acquisitions: A Deep Dive into the Legal Aspects of M&A in France
I. Scrutinizing the Legal Fundamentals of M&A Transaction Completion Mergers and Acquisitions (M&A) transactions necessitate the precise and thorough formulation of the Sale and Purchase Agreement (SPA). A cornerstone document in the process, the SPA represents the formal commitment between the buyer and seller, setting out the terms and conditions of the sale. One of […]
Read